Transcript 0:01 [upbeat music] Welcome to the Rebooting show. I am Brian Morrissey. 0:12 This is a spotlight episode with our partners at DoubleVerify, and I'm very happy to be joined by Jack Marshall, who's the head of news policy content partnerships at DoubleVerify. 0:22 But just as important, Jack and I worked together for a long time. I forget how many years, but it's, it was going back a long ways, right to the early Digiday days, and then Jack left me. 0:33 But then he came back, which- Twice... I was very happy for you. [chuckles] He left me twice, which is terrible. But I, I mean, I t- I like-- I appreciate that you came back. 0:41 Jack's a, was a senior reporter at The Wall Street Journal. He also ran Toolkits, which was, I guess, during the pandemic, right? It was after the pan- no, it was during the pandemic. Yeah. Yep, during. 0:52 Yeah, yeah, during. And then you joined DoubleVerify two years ago, a little over two years ago, as its first head of news. 1:01 And do you remember when you came to me, Jack, and you were, you told me you were joining DoubleVerify? Do you remember what I said to you? I do not. Is it- I've-- Okay. I said- Is it repeatable?... 1:10 "I hope they're paying you a lot, because you're gonna get yelled at a lot by publishers." [laughs] Which is, which is not untrue, necessarily. That was, that was joking, sort of. 1:21 [laughs] But you went over, and at the time, because DoubleVerify is synonymous with, with brand safety, right? And, you know, over the years, talking with publishers, they always, they always complain about, about it. 1:37 They would always, you know, it'd be like, "Well, what's your big..." Remember we used to do the challenge boards? Yeah. You know? Brand safety was always, like, on one of those. 1:45 'Cause they would get caught up in, like, filters, and they always, you know, the Vice, the Vice people in particular always had, like, these, like, examples of, like, writing a story about, like, domestic violence getting caught up in some kind of brand safety filter. 2:00 But tell me what the, just so people know, like, what, what is your role there, and, like, what's, what's the News Accelerator just program? Yeah, yeah. 2:10 So as you said, I, I joined just over two years ago, a newly created role for the company, and basically I head up an initiative across the company called the News Accelerator. 2:21 And broadly, the whole goal of that initiative is to help encourage greater advertiser investment with news content, with journalism, with news publishers more broadly. 2:31 So I work closely with major news publishers and sort of the, the broader publisher community to sort of understand the, the challenges and the opportunities and the frustrations that they have, which you just sort of alluded to. 2:45 But then also I spend a lot of time with advertisers and agencies as well, and helping them sort of understand the opportunities that news presents, and how they can go about capitalizing on, on that effectively. 2:57 So yeah, I think 2:59 you just sort of alluded to this, but you know, I think it's an interesting time to be in this role because a couple years ago, I think a lot of the conversations I was having with publishers was sort of frustration and sort of a lack of understanding around kind of brand safety versus suitability, which, you know, in my book are two different terms. 3:17 Maybe we can get into that. But basically frustrations from publishers around how advertisers were sort of setting up some of the technology tools, like those offered by DV. 3:27 Now I think the conversation has moved on a little bit and, you know, I think I'm increasingly spending my time on, you know, how can I and DV help sort of highlight the, the power of news more generally. Mm-hmm. 3:39 And then obviously, you know, as there's this new kind of wave of, of AI disruption, you know, I think it's becoming more about connecting publishers and advertisers and sort of helping both parties explore, to your point, you know- Yeah... 3:50 in the open there, you know, what ad-supported news is gonna look like in, you know, 12 months, three years, five years, next week. 3:57 So yeah, it's, I think it's sort of evolved over those two years but, you know, primarily my role is working with publishers and figuring out how to connect them with advertisers. 4:05 And the last thing I would say is like, you know, I, I, I'm not selling anything. You know, that's, that's not my role at all. 4:11 It's, it's purely, again, sort of figuring out how DV and how I can, can help support news publishers ultimately to the benefit of, of advertisers as well. Okay. 4:20 So what, two years in, what do you appreciate now more than you did? You know, you knew this space really well from the outside as a reporter and yeah, I don't wanna say outside, inside, you know? 4:33 But you, you, you have a different perspective now from all sides, right? 4:38 So, like, what do you appreciate now that you maybe didn't appreciate as a reporter who had a really good handle on this space, say from the advertiser side, and then let's move to the publisher side? Yeah. 4:50 I think the biggest thing is probably just, like, kind of myths and misconceptions and, like, the power of narratives, I guess, around this stuff. 4:59 You know, I think at some point, like, the concept of safety and suit-suitability became completely blurred, and it's at the point now where they're just sort of used interchangeably. 5:09 But I think, you know, that has really hurt publishers, and I think, you know, it may sound like semantics, but those are sort of fundamentally different concepts. 5:17 So, you know, there is always gonna be content that is unsafe, you know, for, for most brands. 5:22 So adult material, extreme and graphic content, you know, copyright, stuff like that, and DV has what we call a brand safety floor that kind of strips most of that out. But, you know, we see it in the data. 5:34 I'm constantly looking at the data. I checked just before we jumped on this call. You know, for most major publishers, it's like 99.999% of their content is considered what DV would consider safe. 5:46 You know, it doesn't meet that kind of brand risk threat. So really what we're talking about is suitability, right? 5:52 And advertisers are always gonna have kind of preferences around the types of content that they wanna appear alongside. 5:58 You know, we've always, advertisers have always sort of wanted to align with certain- You know, sports people or celebrities and sort of avoid others. 6:06 You know, this is sort of a, a very old sort of marketing conversation that we're having here. 6:10 So I think in answer to your question, you know, it's just this safety, the word safety entered the conversation at some point, and I think has really just hurt publishers because it trickles down, you know, through agencies to sort of the proverbial 24-year-old media buyer, to the hands-on keyboards, and they're worried about something that is really just about suitability and adjacency and alignment. 6:33 And even in like in the trade pubs, right? Like, I see in articles that are making the argument that brand safety is sort of costing news publishers revenue. 6:43 I think just the use of the term brand safety implies there's, you know, something to be worried about there, something unsafe. 6:49 So I know it sounds like a very simple thing, but it's just like the power of this narrative- Yeah... that we're now all sort of fighting and pushing back against. 6:57 And you know, companies like DV have ended up hiring people like me and having initiatives to basically fight this misconception that has just kind of got out of hand. Wait. Who came up with the term safety? 7:07 'Cause I mean, I think this is like al- also part of just, like, the evolution as I get older. 'Cause I'm like, I'm like, "Calm down, people. Like, what are we talking about safety? Nobody's gonna get hurt." 7:16 [laughs] It's a banner ad. [laughs] Like, it's a pre-roll. I, I understand it. Everyone has... There's a lot of CYA in a lot of this. I mean, I think about the great story you did about Nissan, actually, Jack. 7:32 You didn't think I was gonna bring that up, did you? Yes. [laughs] I'd, I'd forgotten about that. You- That was a while ago. I didn't, I didn't forget it. [laughs] No, you, you, you, you reported on... 7:40 I don't know how you found this out, by the way, and it was always suspicious to me, about Nissan ads appearing before some beheading video, like some ISIS beheading video. 7:50 I think it was, like, on YouTube, but maybe it was on somewhere else. You know, I think Nissan was like, "Do you have any idea how our ads, you know, showed up there?" And to me, this story was always one wh- where 8:05 an entire ecosystem got created in which opacity was a feature, not a bug, and that opacity benefited certain, like, a bunch of different people. 8:15 I mean, these things happen for a reason, and one of the downsides of that kind of opacity were these kind of placements, which I think would be deemed, quote-unquote, unsafe or unsavory or whatever. 8:30 You don't- Nissan does not wanna be associated with a beheading video. I think we all would agree on that. But, you know, I think the, the question ends up being, like, 8:41 publishers become collateral damage to that, you know? And then, you know, the, the cure ends up just kinda worsening it, right? Like, the cure ended up being keyword block lists, you know? And 9:00 I, I assume we've moved off that problem, because that was, like, a very blunt tool. We have, yeah. Yeah. I, I j- you know, people still bring up keyword, you know? Yeah. 9:10 Most sort of suitability providers at this point are, you know, way past that. You know, it's using very sophisticated machine learning and AI, you know, to understand the context and the sentiment of an article. 9:22 So, you know, when I see those examples thrown out that, you know, use of the word shoot in a sports article is gonna result in blocked content, that's a very kinda outdated understanding- My God... of, of the tools. 9:34 But- I hope in this age of AI we [laughs] have gotten slightly more- Yeah... sophisticated. You know, so that, that's not happening. But- Okay... you know, to your point, I think, 9:42 you know, there was a concern around safety. The example you brought up, you know, I think is a, is a safety concern for a brand. Right. And I think the pendulum arguably just sort of swung too far the other way. 9:53 You know, ultimately it's advertisers and agencies that are using the tools. 9:58 So I think, you know, it's our role to make sure that they're doing so sort of judiciously and sort of responsibly, and I think most importantly, that they're doing so in a way that enables them to get 10:11 the most out of their media investment. 'Cause I think that's what we're seeing increasingly. 10:14 You know, we do a ton of research via News Accelerator on sort of the performance of news content relative to other types of content, the engagement of news audiences. 10:23 And what we're increasingly seeing, and, like, the message that I'm trying to get out to the market, is sort of FOMO. 10:28 You know, you are missing out on opportunities by, you know, avoiding news entirely or having very sort of conservative approaches. 10:36 So yeah, you know, I think that's sort of the message is that, you know, if you wanna be a good steward of, of your media budget or, you know, if you're on the agency side of, of your client's budget and wellbeing, then, you know, you're, you're doing yourselves and, and your brands a disservice by overlooking news. 10:51 So- Yeah... 10:52 that's increasingly what I'm trying to say to, to the advertiser side, and also sort of equipping publishers with, you know, that data and those talking points so they can go to market sort of equipped to, to make that point as well. 11:03 But what do you hear from advertisers that you think that publishers either don't appreciate because the advertisers don't, like, say it directly to them, or that j- they just don't know? 11:16 Like, I mean, 'cause I think from an advertiser standpoint, remember all the YouTube boycotts attempts, attempted YouTube boycotts? M- maybe you don't because they never stuck. [laughs] I mean- That's something-... 11:29 YouTube's a juggernaut, right? The key word. It doesn't matter that they ran the ad on the Nissan. Still a great story, Jack. Doesn't matter. YouTube's still gonna get, like, all, all the budgets. That's because 11:39 they, they get returns on it. They have to be there, you know? And what I've always wondered is, is this just, like, a product problem? 11:48 Like, whereas, like, I think, like, if I was, you know, an advertiser, I'd be like, "Look, I got, I got a lot of problems here. It's really difficult to, like, you know, sit in this seat. 12:00 If I'm a CMO, whatever the proverbial 18 months, maybe it's 24 months now, you know, I... 12:06 the last thing I need, risk reward, and the risk of- Those, those screenshots that, that for some reason we've talked about for like a generation in this industry is just too high when the reward is, eh. 12:24 Like, there's lots of ways to reach audiences. Do I really wanna reach audiences, you know, when they're like engaged in like, "Are we gonna have World War III?" content? I don't know. 12:36 I mean, if it, if it performs, right? So I think that is, I think maybe sort of their shortcoming is I don't know if in terms of... So to answer your question, yeah, I think, I think it is a product problem. 12:47 I think they, they have not done a great job in selling themselves, in sort of differentiating against, you know, the other opportunities that are out there. 12:55 You know, it's not that there's a risk with, with buying news, but it is maybe more complicated than some of the other sort of opportunities that are out there. So I think, you know, arguably they 13:06 should or could have done a better job in sort of differentiating and, yeah, just telling a better story to the market. 13:13 And again, you know, that is something that I have been focusing on increasingly over the past year or so, and I think publishers are sort of understanding that more. I think it's resonating with, with advertisers. 13:23 You know, I think one thing that is interesting in the two years that I've been here is like that 13:28 sort of narrative around supporting news and, you know, advertisers having a role to play in, you know, and a responsibility for sort of ensuring an informed public has sort of given way to, no, we wanna position news as a business opportunity. 13:44 You know, we wanna put hard data in front of, in front of advertisers that explains to them what they're missing out on. So I, I deem that as sort of positive, positive shift. 13:55 You know, I think they're looking at it more from the advertiser standpoint and saying, "Look, they do have a ton of options available to them. 14:01 Many of them, you know, have great sort of reporting and attribution tied to them. So how do we sort of compete in that world?" 14:08 And, yeah, maybe arguably they've been slow, but, you know, I am encouraged by some of the movement I've seen in the past year or so. Yeah. 14:13 Let, let's talk about that because I also think that, at least my experience of it, was that all of these are real issues, right? 14:21 And then to address them, and maybe it was just the timing, it kinda got caught up in a lot of-- it kinda got lumped in a- as like a DEI type of thing. 14:31 You know, no matter what you think about it, like, it, it, it got lumped in with being good to the climate, being good stewards, being-- like it was almost like, it was almost in like the social work bucket, you know? 14:44 Which is fine when, you know, companies were feeling a lot of pressure to be doing social work, right? 14:53 And, you know, back in 2021, you remember when like Group M was, was saying that their differentiation in the market was around their responsible media framework. 15:04 It had five pillars: brand safety, data ethics, diversity, decarbonization, and funding quality journalism. It got, it got lumped in as like the fifth- Yeah. Yes... 15:17 on, on these, on, on these things that had nothing to do with having the clients make more money, and a lot of that fell away. 15:27 You know, you can argue that it shouldn't have fallen away when, when the, the, when politics changed, and maybe it comes back. I don't know. I, I think that, you know, the argument kinda wasn't on business grounds. 15:43 Yeah. Yeah, completely. And again, I think, again, it may seem like a small thing, but I think I really have seen on the publisher side that mentality shift. So, you know, publishers are coming to me, coming to us. 15:54 So as part of the News Accelerator, we run like a, what we call the Publisher Council. You know, a bunch of maj-major publishers kind of meet with us on a regular basis. We hold what we call like forum events. 16:05 We held a couple in, in New York and in London this year. 16:08 So we, we're looking to publishers to provide us with that feedback constantly, and that is something that they are bringing up, and they are asking us for data that really kind of proves out that business case. 16:18 So, you know, we're going away investing in, in research that shows that ads placed alongside news generate, you know, 20% more engagement, that shows that news is outperforming, you know, other inventory. 16:31 And we, we did a study a couple weeks back, which I think was really interesting, which was around sort of the efficiency piece. So that is factoring in performance relative to cost. Mm-hmm. 16:41 So via, we own a sort of media optimization tool called Stybits. 16:46 So we looked at clients that were using AI optimization for their campaigns and said, "Okay, for those that are optimizing towards certain outcomes, how did inventory on news sites perform with inventory from, you know, elsewhere across the web or elsewhere across app?" 17:01 And we're seeing significant sort of efficiency gains by working with news. So I think what that shows is that news is like, you know, an undervalued opportunity. 17:10 There are bargains to be had for advertisers that are willing to dip a toe. So, you know, it's that type of evidence that I'm trying to take to market to put in front of advertisers so that, 17:23 you know, it's worth going through the extra sort of overhead step of, you know, setting up, you know, tools correctly for, for different publishers or, or whatever it might be. So it's really about that. I don't... 17:35 Not risk reward, but sort of effort to reward. And again, it's that sort of 24-year-old media buyer- Yeah... you know, hands on keyboard that ultimately is having to do this stuff on a Monday morning. 17:46 So how do we get data and sort of education in front of them that makes news sort of like the first place they look and not just like a box that they're trying to check because agency leadership has, has told them to. 17:58 So sorry, that was kind of a, a long-winded answer. Mm-hmm. But I, you know, I think that is a shift that we're seeing. 18:03 And again, like as we look forward over the next sort of three to five years, I think that is gonna be crucial with disruption coming from all sort of angles, is having sort of a clear sense of- You know, the value that they bring to the market. 18:18 And, you know, I do think there is still a place for ad-supported journalism. You know, obviously sort of reader revenue and subscriptions and all of that good stuff are gonna play sort of a major role. 18:29 But I also think it's a sort of an opportunity to rethink the ad experiences a little bit. You know, you brought up sort of the, the banner ad. 18:36 You know, a- as we sort of shift towards AI doing a lot of the heavy lift- heavy lifting on just sort of the pure sort of queries, you know, I think there's an opportunity there once again for, like, more sort of immersive and engaging ad experiences, and it's not just commodity monetizing traffic. 18:53 So I don't know. I'm, I'm sort of hopeful. Publishers have been through this kind of thing a few times before and not- Yeah... necessarily seized the opportunity, but, you know, maybe it'll be different this time. 19:02 [upbeat music] Quick break to encourage you to join our TRB Pro membership program. We are building it around What's Working case studies we've been doing at our salons and events this year. 19:14 I found that media is, at its heart, an execution business. Now, on this podcast, I speak to leaders of media organizations about their business strategies, but those strategies live and die on execution. 19:28 We are featuring a series of What's Working case studies on therebooting.com to highlight initiatives that are gaining traction and to unpack why they're working through the lens of the practitioners leading these initiatives. 19:42 Our first batch of What's Working case studies, available exclusively to TRB Pro members, are from organizations like People Inc, USA Today, The Daily Beast, Outside, and more. 19:53 TRB Pro members also get invitations to our mixers and discounted entrance to TRB events, like our recently completed TRB Audience Summit. 20:02 We'll also do a series of conversational case studies where you get to discuss the initiatives with those who are leading them, and you get access to our private social network devoted to highlighting and unpacking what's working in the market. 20:15 The goal of TRB Pro is to make you better at your job and to enable practitioners to lead the way in creating a sustainable media industry. So please join today. Go to therebooting.com/upgrade. 20:28 A subscription is $200 a year, or if you wanna try it out, a mere $20 a month. I think that's a good deal. So go to therebooting.com/upgrade. So let's say, I mean, this is part of the Media 2031 series that we're doing. 20:43 So give me, give me the case for what this, this landscape looks like in, in five years time and why there is going to be an ad-supported publisher news ecosystem. 20:57 It seems like the direction is against the open web, and the open web was, you know... I mean, this is how n- news publishers got a lot of their, their impressions, right? 21:09 And, you know, that- those have dropped precipitously. Maybe not as much for, for news publishers as, as other types of publishers, but, you know, still, broadly, everyone has been hit by this. 21:21 And, you know, I mean, look, I can see... I had Sarah Fisher on this podcast, and we were talking about, about the open web m- and websites being made for agents increasingly, not for humans. And if... 21:33 And when you are using AI tools, no, they're not there yet, and they haven't affected, like, the, the news experience. But it's hard for me to believe that AI is not gonna be the interface. 21:46 And when I go to publisher news sites, and I understand the reason for it, et cetera, I'm like, "Nobody would choose this experience. Just nobody." 21:54 Like, I ended up on, on one, it was a sports news site, but my, my browser crashed. We're still crashing people's browsers on these sites [chuckles]. It's crazy. I'm like, you're just gonna lose in the market. 22:07 Like, I don't know what else to s- tell you. I don't blame people for using ad blockers or any of that when the, when the experience is so horrifying. So why will this even survive? Like, the... 22:19 'Cause you said that you think that there's space for ad-supported news. 22:22 We have a lot of examples of publishers that are building good, very defensible businesses, but the ad part of it is much smaller than having, particularly on news. You know, it's like look at The New York Times. 22:39 Why is The New York Times gonna spend all their money on Letterboxd? 22:42 You know, they're, they're building an entire bundle of different products, and news is an incredibly important part of that, but it's primarily subscriptions driven. Yeah. 22:54 I mean, there's a lot of different threads to unpack there. But so taking your comment on, like, AI being the interface, like, one thing I've been thinking about, I haven't sort of... 23:03 I don't have a fully formed thought about this, I'm curious on your take. But yeah, I think it comes down to, like, formats, right? 23:09 So, like, text, and text on the open web specifically, I, I agree, I think is gonna be kinda the domain of, of AI and AI agents. So, you know, how users are interacting with that, I don't know. 23:21 But the idea that we're gonna have, you know, large newsrooms of people writing 500-word articles, I think we all agree at this point that is... It's a case of sort of managing decline at this point. 23:32 I mean, in some ways, there's corollaries with print. Like, there's gonna be people that wanna interact with it that way. There are gonna be exceptions, long form features, stuff like that. 23:41 But I think the relationship with text is, is gonna change. And then I think, I know it's a bit of a cliché, but people are naturally gonna gravitate towards, like, the formats that tap into sort of the human element. 23:54 So that is obviously kind of video, audio. 23:57 We're seeing this increasingly with news organizations sort of putting personalities front and center, partnering with influencers, investing more heavily in kind of video and distributed content, and I think that's where the opportunities will be. 24:10 Again, I think getting away from this, like, just commoditize traffic, bring people to a website, show them a banner ad, you know, is, is sort of... It's being forced obviously. 24:20 But I think it is an opportunity to just rethink- The whole experience and say, "Okay, how do we weave advertisers into our content in a way that is way more organic?" 24:31 And, you know, I think we've seen this with influencers over the past five years. They've done a way better job, and I think brands are, are more interested in those types of integrations. So 24:40 yes, I, yeah, I think there is still gonna be a role and, uh, for, you know, ad-supported media, whether it's ad-funded exclusively or straight news. 24:50 Whether it's funded by advertising exclusively, I don't know, but there are gonna be opportunities there. And the other thing is, you know, 24:56 again, with kind of the rise of AI slop and AI-generated content, I do sort of buy into the narrative that people are gonna be looking to brands as shorthand for sort of quality and, you know, integrity and, you know, everything that, use The, the New York Times as an example, everything that that brand stands for, and I think that is portable. 25:16 It doesn't really matter if it's on The New York Times or, you know, on TikTok. 25:20 So yeah, you know, I think all of this is sort of up for debate and, you know, these are the types of conversations I'm having with advertisers now. But yeah, you know, yeah, I mean, do you, do you disagree? 25:31 Are you pessimistic on, like, the idea of having ad-supported news, period? Oh, I think it's gonna be... 25:37 I think it's very difficult to have a high quali- and I think it's gonna be increasingly difficult to have a high quality news company that is primarily supported by standardized advertising, for sure. 25:51 I, I just don't see, you know, the... Nobody's gonna, nobody's founding the next Huffington Post for a reason. Like, I just don't, I don't see a market for that. I think there are, you know, look, there's growth areas. 26:03 The growth areas that I see are around multimodal, so getting out of text in particular and moving into more audio, but primarily video, particularly backed by, like, sort of personality. 26:17 I think that's, like, a good area. And building franchises where you can get high value audiences into events and IRL of all kinds of different things. Building a bundle of lifestyle services around news. 26:31 You know, Jay Rosen was on this podcast, like, a couple years ago, and he said something that really stuck with me, which is s- that news was always a subsidy business, and when you broke apart the bundle, you didn't have the auto section, you didn't have the food section. 26:44 I used to- Yeah... I used to deliver newspapers, Jack. You remember me regaling you with these stories. And- Unfortunately, I do. [laughs] Those newspapers were heavy on Sundays, which I resented at the time. 26:55 I didn't realize that this is, [laughs] this is as good as it got- [laughs]... 'cause they're not as heavy. But, but that's, I mean, and that's what The New York Times has done, right? Yeah. 27:02 It's just recreating the bundle. You know, it has a sports section, it has the cooking section. To your point, they're talking about Letterboxd, you know, the entertainment section. Right. And look at The Athletic. 27:10 Look, maybe they overpaid, probably, but whatever. 27:13 But, like, they have been able to, they, they, they brought the ad model into that, and one of the reasons that they had to was, had to, but, like, that was the opportunity, is because they were able to take... 27:25 They have a lot, they have engagement in their news content, but, like, they're able to then take that and, like, move that into The Athletic. The Athletic is great for that, for advertiser content. I don't think... 27:40 I-- Tell me, you're talking to, to advertisers a- all the time, right? 27:44 Like, I don't think that you, as persuasive as you are, even with a, even with an English accent, that you're gonna be able to convince them [laughs] that it's in their business interest to be on, like, we're attacking Iran stories. 27:58 [laughs] Well, I mean, I think that's where, like, the... So I mean, DV talks a lot about, like, verify, optimize, improve, right? 28:07 So started out on sort of the verification side, you know, reporting was an ad i- in a specific context, you know, was it viewable, right geo, all of that good stuff. 28:17 But then we acquired, as I said, Cybids and then Rockabox, which is, like, the optimization piece, and then the attribution piece, which I think is key. 28:25 So, you know, for news specifically, I think that becomes really interesting because then you can not only say, okay, news does perform really well, but you can also start going a layer deeper when you layer on kind of that quality piece as well and start saying, okay, like, 28:42 do specific types of news drive specific outcomes? Like, maybe political stories or stories about war in the Middle East actually perform really well for brand X, Y, and Z or campaign A, B, and C. 28:54 So I don't think to date we've sort of, like, closed that loop, and obviously that's where the social platforms- Yeah... have done a great job. That has been tough to do in the open web. Nobody's really cracked it. 29:05 But again, like the, I referred to that study that we ran, you know, using Cybids, like, that's what we're seeing. We're seeing, like, significant sort of im- performance gains working with news and efficiency gains. 29:16 So it's just, I think, getting that, again, getting the data, getting the hard evidence in front of advertisers that is, like- Yeah... makes it hard for them to ignore. 29:25 And honestly- And I know it's easy for me 'cause I see it on the back end. Yeah, yeah. 29:27 But it's [laughs] Well, I mean, look, a lot of this, humans are irrational, I feel like, in a lot of ways, and I don't think it's ever been proven, and I don't think it ever will be proven, that because your ad is near bad things that happen in the world and the news reports on bad things that happen in the world, that that does some kind of, like, lasting damage. 29:49 Like, I mean, I can't remember this morning. I'm not gonna remember an ad next to, like, a news article and be like, I'm never... I just don't think it's gonna lodge in my brain. 30:00 Now, I, maybe, maybe there's research that ha- has proven this out, but I just think that this is a case where it's more, you know, I, kind of emotion/CYA driven. Am, am I wrong there? 30:19 No, I think you're right to a degree. 30:21 I, I mean, we, we did a big piece of consumer research where we surveyed, I think it was, like, 22,000 consumers globally- And ask them sort of in the abstract, like, "What do you think of brands that support news by advertising alongside it?" 30:35 And it was, like, 89% either positive or neutral, and within that, it was 43% people saying, "I actually actively value brands that appear in those contexts." 30:48 So again, I think it comes back to that suitability thing, right? Like, if you're Toyota, I understand you not wanting to appear next to a news article about a recall. You know, that just makes sense. 30:59 Like, in that specific content, context, you know, there is sort of a, a suitability concern. So that makes complete sense. 31:06 But yeah, I, you know, I don't think that means you need to avoid news con- con- content entirely. 31:11 And again, that's where on the product side, we spend a lot of time, we use the phrase a lot, scalpel versus sledgehammer. 31:17 You know, how do we sharpen our tools as much as possible so that brand X can go in and, you know, carve out the tiny portions of inventory that are not suitable for whatever reason the CEO i- is, you know, has done what I'm, you know... 31:33 Uh, examples in the press the, the past week or so that are good examples of that, and basically open up on everything else. 31:39 So that's kind of been our message, or my message on the product side is the tools are way more sophisticated now than sort of the keyword example you used. 31:48 So with the right settings in place, you can open up on all news and just be confident that the technology is covering it. So yeah, you know, it's- Is this working? 31:57 Are the more sophisticated tools, are they having an impact that's positive for... Again, I'm not, like, saying the fix is in. 32:07 Like, I mean, ultimately, like, yeah, I would love that, like, you know, news publishers, I have an affinity for them. So, like, I would love for them to, to, to get more demand from, from advertisers. 32:18 I think that'd be wonderful. But at the end of the day, like, I don't know if the demand is there. Like, I mean, is this working to get more advertiser demand to news publishers? It's definitely working. 32:32 You know, the, the conversations that I've been having, and again, over the course of two years, I, I, to some degree, it started with me knocking on doors and saying, "Hey, can we have a conversation about news?" 32:42 You know, at this point, we're, I would say, getting a lot more inbound. You know, on the client side, they're saying, "Hey, you know, we're reading about news in the press. 32:49 We've seen some of your research that you've put out. You know, we wanna make sure that we're not missing out on an opportunity." 32:56 On the agency side, you know, increasingly have agencies coming and saying, you know, "A client has asked us about news," or, you know, "We're putting together a recommendation, you know, is there data that you can share to help us kind of support that case?" 33:08 So yeah, I think it is, I think it's resonating. I think it's driving interesting conversations. 33:15 And then for the brands that we do work with directly, you know, we can help in terms of, like, s- settings and setting up the tools correctly that then enable them to run, you know, if they're running an open web programmatic campaign, they can run across all news sites, safe in the knowledge that their suitability needs are gonna be maintained, and they don't need to be, you know, hitting pause on campaigns if something happens in the news cycle. 33:38 Yeah. 33:38 So I think that piece is just kind of education, and you know, that's something that's kind of top of mind for me is how do I sort of help educate the market more broadly that, again, the tools have moved on compared to where they were five years ago, and you don't-- It's not sort of a hands-on, high-overhead thing to, to run a news campaign. 33:58 So, you know, you don't need to block at the domain level. That's a big thing, right? 34:02 Like, step one is a lot of brands are using inclusion and exclusion lists that they apply to all of their campaigns, you know, programmatic or not. 34:11 And if you don't make the cut, then you're never gonna get the opportunity. Suitability then is not even in the conversation because you're, you know, you're not on the plan. 34:20 So I, I'm trying to sort of promote the use of our tools and settings that enable people to open up with news pubs. And yeah, you know, I think advertisers are more curious. 34:30 It's, you know, I'd like to say it's moving quicker than it is, but I, I do feel like it's moving in the right direction. What about AI content? 34:38 Like, are, are, are you guys thinking about, like, tools that, and I don't know if there's a demand for this from advertisers. Like, do they care about running on what is being called, quote unquote, "AI slop"? 34:51 And I think that there's a lot of gradations. Like, I saw, I saw a trailer for some, I don't know if you saw this, for, like, "Nuremberg." 34:59 It's some, like, AI movie that's being created, and it was like, wow, this has come a long way from Will Smith eating spaghetti. Um- Yeah, that's the test, right? [laughs] I mean, I was like, this is pretty good. 35:11 So I think AI slop might be y- you know, there's gradations to that. 35:16 But I wonder, look, the, the overall direction, I don't know, I don't know what the current figures are, but I would assume that, you know, eventually, you know, 99% of the content will be synthetic, right? 35:31 I would guess in, in, in five years. 35:33 I don't know what that does to the market because, you know, you, you-- I could see, I could see some advertisers saying, "I don't, I don't wanna be next to AI-created content," or, "I, I don't-- I wanna filter them out, that out." 35:50 But I could see others who are just like, "Who is it? Who am I to judge?" Like, if, if people want to engage with a AI-created cartoon monkey, like, video, great. No problem. Yeah. 36:07 So the short answer to, to your question is yes, you know, we're investing in a, in a lot of tools to help advertisers understand, you know, AI-generated content versus different types of content. 36:17 But I think to your point, it's those gradations, right? Yeah. 36:21 So, like, our, our role is just as a technology company is to provide options and say, you know, this firmly sits within that AI slop bucket, or is it that end of the spectrum? 36:33 This in the middle, like maybe AI generated, but, you know, is generating an audience, is generating engagement, maybe for your brand that is suitable. 36:43 So we are just trying to bring sort of transparency for the buyer side. Ultimately, you know, what advertisers decide to buy is, is up to them. But yeah, you know, it's how do we help them understand that content? 36:56 And to your point, as more of this content is AI generated, it's not gonna be binary, it's not gonna be slop or human. Yeah. It's gonna be on some sort of, you know, spectrum. 37:07 So again, it's like that scalpel, sledgehammer thing. It's like, how do we continue to slice as finely as possible and give advertisers sort of as granular sort of visibility and optionality? 37:18 But yeah, I think that'll be an interesting space, and then we'll see some brands that wanna be all the way to one side of the spectrum and other brands that push it further. And again, sort of that 37:28 optimize and improve thing then becomes very interesting because you might find some interesting pockets of inventory where, I don't know, some sort of AI generated- Yeah. 37:37 Well, I- Some popular Yeah, I guess what I wonder-... performing very well... is, you know, when supply, supply will be infinite, right? 37:44 Like, I, it just like, you know, if there's anything there that, that these, these AI engines are already great at, it's, it's producing like an incredibly large amount [laughs] 37:55 of information, whether you want it or not. I like ask like one question, all of a sudden a wall of words comes at me, I'm like, "Whoa, enough." But it, it is gonna be basically infinite, infinite supply, and that will, 38:09 even if individually most of the stuff like is ignored. Like, I mean, you think about like software, people can spin up so much software now and apps and whatnot, but like, you know, nobody uses them. 38:20 But at the same time, some few people do, and I think engagement and attention ends up getting even more dispersed, right? And I just don't know whether 38:32 that ends up benefiting news publishers in some ways in that, like, they're, they can like position themselves as a scarce, you know, commodity versus like, you know how it is. 38:45 It's like everything has become, the, everything has been commoditized, and whether they can regain scarcity in some way in this world of infinite synthetic content. Yeah. I mean, yeah. 39:00 I don't know the answer to that, but I do think that's what publishers are hoping. So yes, scarcity, but again, it kind of comes back to that human element, right? 39:08 Like if it's human generated, by definition it's scarce, so. Right. Again, you know, or, you know- Well, that's why I think like news is, is gonna be driven. 39:18 Yeah, they're gonna use AI tools, but all the publishers I talk to, they're like, "We cannot give up the human element." 39:25 Like, I mean, we just cannot, and that for just, you know, ethical reasons, but also market positioning. I, I feel like there is a lot of, of hesitance, hesitancy, and I think it's right to give up on that. 39:41 And we don't know, like I, I like the idea of there being some kind of like, you know, human premium. It sounds great. This human premium, that's a good service. 39:50 But I always say, you get out in the market, it'll tell you what it wants. It might not be what you wanna hear. This is true. But I mean, I'm hearing the same thing from publishers though. 39:59 I mean, it seems like that's where they are sort of positioning themselves for this next, you know, wave, and like, I don't know, maybe the pivot to video is just a little early. Yeah. 40:10 So what are like, what are three things do you think that publishers should be doing now to, you know, improve their chances? 40:19 Like, I mean, you know, a lot of this debate to me just over the last several years has always been like, "Wow, they need to do this. They..." I keep hearing they, they, they, they, and I'm like, "Okay, well, what..." 40:33 I'm like a focus on what you can control guy. So like if, if publisher is focusing on, on what they can control, like what are the, what are the things that they should be doing? I mean, broad question. 40:44 I think like step one, and you know, this will, it, it's become a cliche at this point, but is, you know, focus on sort of generating like actual relationships with their audience. I think focus on brand. 40:57 Like brand is the one defensible thing, right? So again, we talked about The New York Times. You know, we're gonna see the whole kind of tier two 41:06 news publisher segment, I think start to face some challenges if people are just winding up there through Google News and, you know, the, the brands don't actually resonate. So I think 41:18 again, it's pretty obvious, but like invest in content that builds a brand that, you know, actually has a meaningful connection with people. 41:27 The second part I think we talked about, but like on the advertising side, it's like just make a strong business case. 41:32 I don't know, just the idea that advertisers have some sort of, you know, responsibility to support news, you know, I think is, it's not gonna fly. 41:42 [laughs] So let's just focus on, again, to your point, control the things you can control, influence the things you can influence, and let's work together to take, you know, data and evidence to the market that can sort of stand you in the best footing possible. 41:56 And then the last piece, which I'm curious on your thoughts on this as well, is like the collective action piece. So, you know, publishers have never, or news publishers have never been good at kind of banding together. 42:08 You know, there were efforts on the ad side, you know. I'm sort of curious what's gonna happen on the AI side with some of the coalitions there around licensing. But you never know. 42:18 You know, if we start to see publishers cooperating through those types of initiatives, then maybe on the advertising side there's some opportunities that will arise as well. 42:27 But again, do not have a good track record of that, but it'll be interesting to see if AI kind of brings people to the table to cooperate a bit more than, than they have done in the past. 42:36 Yeah, it's, that's always been one of those, I mean, we've talked about it in the newsroom over the years [chuckles] like, you know, publishers are generally... 42:43 I mean, there are good reasons for the antitrust and all that, but they're, they, they haven't been the most organized. 42:49 I think a lot of times, you know, with AI licensing, I hear people make compare- comparisons to, like, the music industry. It's like, "Well, look what they did do with Spotify. We're gonna do, we're gonna do that." 43:01 And, you know, the difference was, for better or worse, the music industry, kind of an oligopoly. It's smaller now. You know? It's smaller, but it's like an oligopoly. 43:11 There's, like, a few different labels, and look, the artists have long been kind of screwed over by the labels. 43:18 But at the same time, it's like, oh, well, you know, when Spotify needed to cut deals, it, it had, like, five different entities to go to, and they could, they could, you know, get 80-plus percent of the market. 43:31 The, you know, this industry is way more, way more fragmented, and so I think that is, that's, that's gonna be a challenge. 43:41 And that's why, like you say, like, second-tier, second-tier news publishers, that's definitely, I mean, that's gonna be a big challenge for sure. 43:49 Not a, not insurmountable one, but, you know, I think these are the types of, like, difficult decisions that you, that news publishers are, are making, like, as, as we speak [chuckles]. 44:00 So yeah, it'll be interesting to see, you know, how that pans out over the next few years. 44:04 Okay, so for, for publishers listening that want to, you know, get involved in any way, what, what, what would, what should they do? 44:13 Yeah, you can go to doubleverify.com/news-accelerator, or just reach out to me directly. Would absolutely love to, to work with, you know, publishers of all sizes across the spectrum. 44:27 We are building out, as I said, sort of a, a news publisher council, but then also what we call the broader network. 44:32 So we are looking for feedback sort of across the board, again, to help sort of inform what we're doing via, via News Accelerator, but also help inform the way that we are talking to advertisers to make sure that their sort of interests and, and priorities are, are represented there. 44:47 So yeah, would, would love to hear from anybody thinking about this stuff. Awesome. Jack, thanks so much. This was fun. Thanks a lot, Brian. Appreciate it. [outro music]