PRESENTED BY OMEDA
Build a smarter audience strategy
65% of media companies have zero audience growth strategy — just vibes and hope.
That’s a bet you can’t win. We tapped leading media pros to build the fix: a no-fluff guide + ready-to-use templates for a real, top-down strategy.
Download the blueprint — prioritize audience needs, execute with confidence, and make the case to your execs in one shot.
The post-scale publisher playbook
The BuzzFeed store in LaGuardia is a reminder of both publishing’s past and future. It’s the past because BuzzFeed as a cultural touchstone is now a historical artifact, but the use of a media brand to sell neck pillows and mints is also part of the future.
On this week’s edition of The Rebooting Show, I spoke with Ryan Pauley, president of Penske Media’s PMX division, which houses the publishing brands of the combined company following PMC’s acquisition of Vox Media’s stable of brands, including The Verge, Eater and SB Nation. Ryan echoed a lot of what is emerging as a post-scale consensus when it comes to the way forward.
The end of empty programmatic.
There’s no original sin of publishing – too many to narrow it to one – but separating the media impression from the user data is a prime candidate. That doomed publishers to be empty vessels to attract attention while the data on the user frequently came from intermediaries or the ad buyer. The user data was more valuable than the raw attention. I know plenty of ad tech founders who have big boats, far fewer publishing execs.
“The reality is a business built on anonymous page view audiences are largely over. It’s not zero today, but it’s certainly declining and will continue to do so,” Ryan said.
In many ways, events are the new programmatic, as Troy said on a recent edition of PvA. I found that a smart formulation because open-web programmatic was always the easy button. You didn’t sell the impressions, so why not eke out some yield from a collection of logos on a landscape slide? Audiences are far smaller – The Verge lost 85% of its traffic, according to Growtika – so that kind of volume approach is no longer tenable.
It’s the brand, stupid.
I would look around resort ballrooms in Key Biscayne and Vail during the scale era and see a weird mish mash of inscrutable middlemen promising incremental yield, well-known legacy and digital publishers and SEO arbitrageurs. So much of what was discussed in sponsor sessions was esoteric ad tech gibberish. Everyone nodded along as if this was where the value lay.
Turns out media is still media. The value lies in brands. You are not going to win on ad ops.
“The audiences that we make the most money from are willing to do the most with us – give us an email address, subscribe, attend an event, whatever that might be,” Ryan said. “That’s where we stay focused. The raw numbers matter less than do we have the right types of audiences.”
There’s no single playbook.
People Inc is instructive because it is the largest publisher and the logic of the company’s original DNA was so geared to a different world. It relied on search traffic and ran a single playbook across brands. Now it’s running a different playbook across its brands as part of an inversion strategy. It’s now in the ice tea business.
PMX houses 25 brands, a mishmash of consumer focused titles (Rolling Stone, Eater, PopSugar) and B2B (WWD, various Hollywood trades, Sportico) mostly in cultural areas like Hollywood, music, art, sports. PMC has the advantage of always favoring a decentralized model that pushed operating decisions to the brand level. That’s critical now, as every brand will need to run a different playbook. The challenge for these companies is finding the efficiencies of scale without imposing a monolithic strategy.
“The period of building a company and fitting brands into the company is over,” Ryan said. “The future of The Verge’s business is very different than the future of Eater’s business and SB Nation and Billboard. You have to have a model that enables teams to move really fast and attack opportunities that are in the best interest of the brand.”
Impact over attention.
The key tenet of the scale era was that attention is what matters. The idea was that the only scarce asset is consumer attention. The entire system commoditized attention as an asset class to be financialized. That led to something of a subprime crisis as the incentives of a financialized attention economy pushed publishers to seek out cheap pageviews through SEO and social. There's a reason we got hundreds of Game of Thrones recaps and the infamous “what time does the Super Bowl start” humiliation ritual.
Now, it’s about impact. It’s not about getting people’s attention, it’s about getting them to do something. You need to get their email to get out of the anonymous user business. You need to get them to attend events, join a community or buy ice tea. In this construct, intellectual property is far more valuable than units of attention aka pageviews. That’s why events are the new programmatic.
“The brands in our portfolio have impact on their industries. Hollywood still runs on breaking news from Deadline. [A] Rolling Stone cover can still launch a career for a new breakthrough artist. When Eater puts a new restaurant on a map, it drives sales incrementally,” Ryan said.
Build multimodal franchises.
Building IP is not just in a monolithic brand. Publishers need to create franchises that go well beyond webpages to encompass audio, video and IRL. It’s quite passe to launch a new podcast. You launch a franchise with a newsletter, podcast, video and event offshoot. And often you attach personalities to these for added leverage but not so much that you’re left empty handed should they leave.
This approach is to go broader but to do so, brands need to focus narrower. Traffic required smearing a brand into any area where there was available attention. That bled the brands of any distinctiveness and led many to be shuffled off to the SEO glue factory.
“Each brand needs to focus very exclusively on what the purpose it serves its audience,” Ryan said. “Now people have historically thought focus means smaller. That’s not necessarily the case. You can have a more focused approach to your relationship with your audience, but do it in a very ambitious way.”
PRESENTED BY BEEHIIV
Inside TechCrunch’s newsletter transformation
TechCrunch has long been known for newsletters like Mobility and StrictlyVC, but behind the scenes, slow workflows imposed by rigid tools held them back. After moving to beehiiv, everything changed, Mobility grew 14% in two months, StrictlyVC grew 4%, and editors could publish faster, experiment freely, and cut through dev bottlenecks. Cleaner segmentation improved deliverability and analytics, while new revenue levers, from sponsorships to paid options, opened up. With beehiiv, TechCrunch quickly turned its newsletters into a smarter engine for reach, retention, and revenue.
The independent grind
After political commentator Chris Cillizza was laid off from CNN in December 2022, he went the independent path with a newsletter and YouTube channel. His verdict nearly four years in: Running a small business is hard.
“There remains a misperception among people in legacy media that what independent media means is you put up a Substack, you explain the like why I left for independent media, you write that post, and the money just pours in,” he said on PvA. “You can buy that villa in Tuscany you always wanted. And what I say to people is, ‘Look, man, like I fucking grind. I write two things a day for Substack and I make two eight-plus minute videos and separate videos a day for YouTube, every single day.’”
See the conversation with Chris on the contours of a classic Washington scandal, the tide turning against the classic performative broadcast journalism style, and the enduring problem of journalism for journalists.
TRB PRO
In last week's What's Working: How Skift is keeping its events premium.
Read the case study to learn:
Don’t sell the room by the lead.
Keep the stage editorial.
Watch where the business happens.
Read the case study · Not a member? Join TRB Pro
Send me a note with your feedback by hitting reply.
For sponsorship information, contact Richard Jamieson at [email protected].




