I’m in Chicago today. Tonight, we are gathering publishing product leaders for a dinner salon to discuss how publishers are bringing AI into day-to-day operations. I find a big gap in adoption. I ask groups of product and audience development people regularly how many use an MCP and am surprised at how many hands go up.

In this week’s What’s Working case study, The Atlantic’s svp of business development and strategic partnerships Mary Liz McCurdy details how the publisher is striking pay per query deals with AI data resellers.

01 Google Zero is forcing a shift to loyalty

I don’t talk to a publisher that isn’t focused on building direct relationships with their audience rather than drive-by traffic from search engines and social. It turns out that loyalty is an important signal for Google. Sharon Profis, vp of audience, shared with me on The Rebooting Show data from the Raptive network of sites that shows how publishers with growing Google referrals had the strongest referral traffic, the strongest social engagement and the largest branded search audiences. “We’re getting much closer to a world where those things are actually inextricably connected,” she said. Also of note: Email page views grew 4.5% year over year, while email revenue grew 36%. Direct traffic was second in revenue performance and social was third. Search and LLM referrals trailed behind. Listen to my conversation with Sharon.

02 Email’s click problem

Email open rates stopped being a reliable measure of engagement some time ago. That led to a shift of focus to clicks. Now these two are unreliable thanks to security bots and other bots. At yesterday’s virtual roundtable on email metrics, sponsored by Beehiiv, we discussed how publishers are using polls and feedback options to drive verifiable engagement.Bad engagement data forces a choice about how long to keep readers on the engaged list. One publisher is weighing cutting its window from 180 days to 90 or 120, which is better for deliverability but leaves a smaller list for ad sales.

03 AI as an email killer

Sometime after email was invented, its demise was predicted. This cycle has continued ever since. The growth of personal agents — I’m excited for Claude Duet — is the next threat. Matt Paulson, CEO of Marketbeat, believes this threat, like all those that came before, will fizzle. Normal people aren’t going to use these agents rather than their inbox. I mostly agree for the short term, but AI mediated inboxes are inevitable. And email itself is getting clogged with endless AI-generated pitches. This will change email. It will continue as an infrastructure layer, but more information will be extracted by AI interfaces, whether agents or Gmail’s AI inbox. This will reward those who go beyond the inbox with multimodal strategies.

PRESENTED BY OMEDA

Omeda: Signals to Revenue: Upsell & Cross-Sell Guide for Media

The most valuable audience you’ll reach this quarter is one you already have — if you can read the signals.

Upsell and cross-sell don't fail because of lack of effort. They fail because the signals are scattered and no one can see them.

See how engagement, content affinity, lifecycle, intent, and more can reveal your next revenue opportunity with Omeda's new guide: Signals to Revenue: Upsell & Cross-Sell Guide for Media. It's the perfect playbook for audience directors and managers in media & publishing.

Included in the Guide:

  • The Expansion Signal Taxonomy

  • A Signal-to-Action Framework

  • The Expansion Signal Audit Worksheet

WHAT’S WORKING / TRB PRO

How The Atlantic is dealing with AI data resellers

In this week's What's Working: The Atlantic is cutting usage-based deals with agentic search platforms.

WHY IT MATTERS

The first AI licensing deals offered protections and compensation but sent limited traffic and subscriptions. Now The Atlantic is betting on getting paid each time an AI agent uses its content. “The reason I like it is [this approach] scales if it actually works,” said Mary Liz McCurdy, SVP of business development and strategic partnerships.

WHAT YOU’LL LEARN

  • How The Atlantic gets paid when AI agents use its content through Parallel’s Index

  • The contract terms it puts in place to make sure it’s compensated and protected

  • What early data shows about the queries its content is answering

What’s Working case studies are for TRB Pro members. Join for $200 a year or try it out for $20 per month.

Send me a note with your feedback by hitting reply.

For sponsorship information, contact Richard Jamieson at [email protected].